Amazon launched the first Echo Show in 2017 as an extension of its Echo lineup that started in 2014. This device added a screen to Alexa’s voice capabilities for visual interactions like video calls and recipes. Over the years, Amazon expanded the series with models featuring larger displays and advanced features. For a deeper dive into one of these models, check out the Amazon Echo Show 8 (3rd gen) review to see how it performs in real-world settings.
Table of Contents
On the other side, Google introduced its Home Hub in 2018, later rebranded as Nest Hub in 2019 after integrating Nest into its hardware division. The lineup grew for enhanced audio and camera support. Choosing between these devices can be tough due to their distinct ecosystems and features, sparking discussions around Google Nest Hub vs Echo Show. This article breaks down key aspects through comparisons across all models to guide your decision effectively.
Compact 7-inch display with sharp visuals and solid sound. Strong Google Assistant integration with sleep tracking and smart home control focus.
Large 15.6-inch Full HD display with widget-based interface. Works well as a family hub for calendars, streaming, and Alexa-powered controls.
Quick Comparison Table
| Features | Amazon Echo Show Series | Google Nest Hub Series |
| Voice Assistant | Alexa | Google Assistant |
| Screen Sizes | 5.5″, 8″, 10.1″, 15.6″ | 7″, 10″ |
| Price Range (approx.) | $90 – $280 | $100 – $230 |
| Camera | Available on most models | Available only on Max model (base has none for privacy) |
| Audio Quality | Good, with spatial audio on select models | Excellent, with Ambient EQ and better bass on Max |
| Smart Home Integration | Built-in Zigbee hub on some, extensive Alexa routines | Seamless Google Home integration, Chromecast support |
| Video Calling | Supported via Alexa app and services | Supported via Google Meet/Duo |
| Unique Features | Adaptive screen brightness, photo frame mode, more model variety | Sleep sensing (on base model), gesture controls, stronger Google ecosystem integration |
For a detailed look at a budget-friendly option, read the Amazon Echo Show 5 review to see how it fits smaller spaces. Consider your space and usage when reviewing the details.
Amazon Echo Show vs Google Nest Hub: Which Model Is More Suitable for You?
Buy Amazon Echo Show if
-
you seek size variety for different rooms
-
You need built-in hubs for extensive control
-
You prefer strong audio options
-
You need integration with Prime Video and Alexa+ for AI enhancements
Don't Buy Amazon Echo Show if
-
You dislike potential ads on the screen
-
You prefer fully on-device processing for privacy
-
You avoid subscription fees for advanced features
Buy Google Nest Hub if
-
You prioritize Google app synergy
-
You prefer sleep sensing without cameras
-
You seek minimalist looks that blend into decor
-
You want affordable entry into smart displays
Don't Buy Google Nest Hub if
-
You need video calling on base models
-
You expect frequent hardware innovations
-
You require web browsing capabilities directly on the device
How We Tested Amazon Echo Show and Google Nest Hub
The testing process involved setting up every model in real home environments like kitchens, bedrooms, and living rooms to assess their performance in daily scenarios. Devices handled tasks such as music playback, recipe displays, smart device control, and video streaming, addressing the Google Hub vs Echo Show comparison directly. Audio quality underwent evaluation in various noise levels with measurements for volume, clarity, and bass response. Displays faced checks for brightness, color accuracy, and angle visibility under different lighting conditions.
Smart home compatibility got tested with over 50 devices from brands like Philips Hue and Ring, ensuring insights for the Google Nest Hub versus Amazon Echo Show debate. Video calls simulated family interactions, while privacy features saw activation and data review. Testing spanned several weeks to include software updates from 2025, ensuring insights reflect long-term performance and reliability. For more on a related device, explore the Amazon Echo Hub review to see how it complements smart home setups.
Expert Opinion on Smart Displays
Technology experts highlight the Echo Show series for its diverse sizes, with the new Echo Show 21 standing out for family organization and entertainment, fueling discussions on Google Nest Hub vs Alexa. They note Alexa’s improvements in conversational AI through updates like Alexa+. Others praise the Nest Hub’s ambient design but point out the need for hardware refreshes beyond the 2021 models.
Analysts recommend the Nest Hub 2nd Gen for bedside applications due to its sleep sensing, while favoring the Echo Show 8 for its balanced performance in midsize spaces, making the Amazon Echo vs Google Nest Hub choice context-dependent. Overall, experts suggest Echo Show for Amazon ecosystems and Nest Hub for Google integration in 2025 setups. Curious about another smart speaker? Check out the Google Nest Audio review for audio-focused insights.
Key Differences Between Amazon Echo Show and Google Nest Hub
The Echo Show lineup offers five models with screens ranging from 5.5 inches to 21 inches, including rotating displays on the Echo Show 10 and built-in Fire TV on larger versions, making it a strong contender in the Echo Show vs Google Home comparison. Nest Hub provides three options focused on compact 7-inch and 10-inch screens, with sleep sensing on the 2nd Gen and a camera only on the Max. Alexa emphasizes Amazon services like Prime Video, while Google Assistant excels in search and mapping.
Audio and smart home features vary, with Echo models often including built-in hubs for direct control. Nest prioritizes on-device processing for privacy. These distinctions help you align the device with your daily routines and existing tech. Echo devices support more video calling options across all models, while Nest limits advanced features to the Max, impacting the Google Home vs Echo Show decision. For a closer look at a premium model, read the Amazon Echo Show 10 review.
Design and Display: Echo Show vs Nest Hub
Echo Show designs cater to a variety of room setups with options from compact to large formats. The Echo Show 5 features a small footprint suitable for nightstands or desks with its 5.5-inch screen that adjusts brightness automatically. Mid-sized models like the Echo Show 8 provide an 8-inch HD display in a slim frame for counters or shelves.
Larger versions such as the Echo Show 10 include a 10.1-inch screen on a rotating base that follows your movements for better visibility during activities. The Echo Show 15 and Echo Show 21 offer wall-mountable designs with 15.6-inch and 21-inch Full HD screens respectively that double as digital photo frames or entertainment hubs with vibrant colors and wide viewing angles, relevant for the Amazon Echo Show vs Google Nest Hub Max debate.
Nest Hub models emphasize a minimalist aesthetic that blends into home decor seamlessly. The Nest Hub 1st Gen and 2nd Gen both use a 7-inch touchscreen with Ambient EQ technology to match surrounding light conditions for a natural appearance. The Nest Hub Max expands to a 10-inch display with a fabric-covered base that reduces glare in bright environments.
While Echo provides more size flexibility for specific placements, Nest focuses on subtle integration without overwhelming the space. You select based on whether you need versatility in sizing or a discreet profile.
Voice Assistants Compared: Alexa vs Google Assistant
Alexa on Echo Show devices handles a wide range of commands with natural flow, from managing shopping lists tied to Amazon Prime to setting up complex routines for daily tasks. The 2025 introduction of Alexa+ enhances this with generative AI capabilities that allow for more conversational interactions and personalized suggestions based on your habits, strengthening the case for Alexa Show vs Google Hub. For example, it can plan dates or recommend outfits considering weather data. This upgrade is available on models like Echo Show 8, 10, 15, and 21, with a subscription fee or free for Prime members to access advanced features like task automation across services.
Google Assistant on Nest Hub responds quickly to queries with strong contextual understanding drawn from Google’s search engine for detailed answers on topics like directions or facts. The transition to Gemini AI in 2025 adds even more refinement to responses, handling follow-up questions and multilingual support effectively. It integrates deeply with Google apps for calendar management or YouTube playback.
While Alexa excels in transactional and entertainment tasks within the Amazon ecosystem, Google Assistant stands out for informational searches and natural language processing. For another Google option, consider the Google Home review.
Smart Home Integration: Which Device Works Best?
Echo Show models embed smart home hubs in versions like the Echo Show 8, 10, 15, and 21, supporting protocols such as Zigbee, Matter, and Thread for direct connectivity to thousands of devices without needing additional bridges, a critical factor in the Amazon Echo Show vs Google debate. You control elements like lights from Philips Hue, thermostats, or locks through voice or touch interfaces. The Alexa+ update in 2025 allows voice setup of advanced routines and provides overviews of connected devices, making management more intuitive for Amazon-centric setups.
Nest Hub connects through the Google Home app with Thread and Matter support across all models, enabling control of compatible gadgets like Nest thermostats or cameras. The 2nd Gen includes sleep sensing for automations that adjust lighting or temperature based on your rest patterns, enhancing the Google Home Hub vs Echo Show discussion.
While Echo offers broader built-in hub capabilities for diverse ecosystems, Nest provides smoother integration for users already invested in Google products. Your existing smart devices influence which system fits better. For a broader perspective, explore Which One Is Best for Your Smart Home?
Audio and Video Quality: Which One Sounds Better?
Echo Show audio performance scales with model size to suit different room needs. The Echo Show 5 delivers clear vocals and improved bass through its 1.75-inch speaker for smaller spaces. Models like the Echo Show 8 feature dual 2-inch neodymium speakers with spatial audio for immersive listening experiences.
Larger units such as the Echo Show 10 and 21 include tweeters and woofers for deeper lows and balanced sound during music or video playback, a key point in Amazon Echo Show vs Google Hub comparisons. Video quality supports HD streaming from services like Prime Video or Netflix with sharp visuals on bigger screens.
Nest Hub provides consistent audio for everyday use across its lineup. The 2nd Gen enhances bass by 50 percent over the 1st Gen with a full-range speaker ideal for podcasts or alarms. The Max adds a subwoofer and tweeters for richer output suitable for rooms.
Video streaming from YouTube or Netflix appears smooth, though limited by smaller displays compared to Echo’s range. Echo generally leads in powerful audio for entertainment, while Nest offers balanced clarity without distortion. For another audio-focused option, see the Amazon Echo Sub Review.
Price and Value: Which Smart Display Should You Buy?
The Echo Show 5 starts at around $90 as an affordable entry point with essential features like a camera and display for basic tasks, making it a focal point in Amazon Echo Show vs Google Home Hub discussions. Mid-tier options like the Echo Show 8 at $150 deliver enhanced audio and adaptive content for everyday use. Higher-end models such as the Echo Show 10 at $250 include rotation for dynamic interactions, while the Echo Show 15 and 21 range from $280 to $400 with Fire TV integration for comprehensive entertainment. Value increases if you subscribe to Alexa+ for advanced AI, free with Prime membership.
Nest Hub 2nd Gen prices at $100 offer sleep tracking and Google integration as a budget-friendly choice. The Max at $230 adds a camera and better sound for those needing video capabilities. Without new models in 2025, Nest provides steady value through app updates. Echo suits users seeking size variety and Amazon perks, whereas Nest appeals to Google loyalists focused on simplicity and affordability. For a compact alternative, check out the Amazon Echo Pop review.
User Reviews and Feedback
Echo Show users frequently commend the series for its versatility in various home settings, a key aspect of Nest Hub vs Amazon Echo discussions. Many highlight the Echo Show 10’s rotating base as useful for following recipes in kitchens without repositioning. The larger Echo Show 21 receives praise for family organization with its expansive screen. However, some mention occasional ads on the interface and software glitches in updates. Overall ratings on sites like Amazon and Reddit average 4.5 stars, with appreciation for audio improvements in 3rd Gen models.
Nest Hub feedback centers on its reliability and ease of use for daily routines. Users value the 2nd Gen’s sleep sensing for better rest insights without wearables. The Max earns positive notes for video calls and sound quality. Complaints include stagnation in hardware since 2021 and occasional response lags. Reviews maintain high scores around 4.5 stars, favoring Nest for seamless Google app ties. For a kid-friendly option, see the Amazon Echo Pop Kids review.
Privacy and Security: How Do Echo Show and Nest Hub Protect Your Data?
All Echo Show models feature physical buttons to disable the microphone and shutters for the camera, ensuring users can prevent accidental audio or video monitoring, an important point often raised in comparisons with Google Nest devices. You can access and delete voice recordings through the Alexa app with ease. Data encryption secures transmissions, and 2025’s Alexa+ shifts some processing to the cloud but maintains user controls for history management. Features like Ring integration include end-to-end encryption for video feeds.
Nest Hub uses mute switches on devices to disable microphones and cameras where present. On-device processing keeps audio and visuals local to minimize cloud exposure. You erase data via the Google app, and no storage occurs for unrecognized commands. Both systems prioritize local handling for sensitive info, with Nest emphasizing edge computing over Echo’s evolving cloud approach. For an alternative smart speaker, explore the Amazon Echo Spot review.
Which Is Better for Video Calls: Echo Show or Nest Hub?
Echo Show includes cameras on most models for versatile calling options through Alexa, Skype, or Drop In features, making it a strong contender in Alexa Echo Show vs Google Nest Hub comparisons. The Echo Show 8 and 10 use 13MP cameras with auto-framing to keep participants centered during conversations. Larger screens on the Echo Show 15 and 21 enhance group calls with clear visuals even in low light. This makes Echo suitable for frequent family or work communications.
Nest Hub limits video capabilities to the Max model with its 6.5MP wide-angle camera supporting Duo or Meet apps. It offers Face Match for personalized greetings but lacks rotation or auto-framing. Basic Nest Hubs handle audio calls only. Echo provides more consistent video across its lineup, while Nest suffices for occasional use on the Max. For another perspective, check out the Google Nest Hub review.
Final Verdict: Amazon Echo Show or Google Nest Hub?
You evaluate your current tech setup and specific requirements to make the best choice between these smart displays, a decision often framed as which is better: Google Nest Hub or Amazon Echo. The Echo Show series in 2025 boasts a wide array of models from compact to large screens with features like motorized rotation on the Echo Show 10 and Fire TV on bigger units for streaming.
Alexa+ adds advanced AI for proactive assistance, ideal if you use Amazon services heavily. Nest Hub remains focused on compact designs with the 2nd Gen’s sleep tracking and the Max’s camera, enhanced by Google Home app updates for customization.
If you’re considering other smart speakers for specific needs, such as for older users, read about the smart speaker for seniors to explore user-friendly options.
Which smart display has better sound quality?
The Amazon Echo Show generally delivers richer and louder sound with deeper bass, making it better for music and video calls. The Google Nest Hub has clear audio but is more balanced for voice and casual listening.
Which device is better for smart home control?
The Google Nest Hub integrates more smoothly with Google Home and Google Assistant devices, while the Amazon Echo Show is more powerful if you already use Alexa-compatible products.
How do the screens compare between Echo Show and Nest Hub?
The Echo Show models typically feature brighter and higher resolution screens, making them better for streaming video. The Nest Hub has a softer, more natural display that is ideal for ambient use like photo frames and home dashboards.
Which one is better for video calls?
The Echo Show supports video calling with built-in cameras and works with Alexa’s Drop-In and Zoom. The Nest Hub does not have a camera on the smaller model, so it only supports audio calls and Google Duo on select versions.
Which smart display is more budget-friendly?
The Google Nest Hub is generally less expensive, offering strong value for basic smart home use. The Echo Show tends to cost more but includes better audio, camera features, and broader Alexa skills.
Read More
