Amazon Echo Show 8 (1st gen) vs Amazon Echo Show 8 (2nd gen): Which Smart Display Should You Buy?
In the ever-evolving world of smart home technology, choosing between different generations of the same device can feel like splitting hairs. But when it comes to the Amazon Echo Show 8, the differences between the first and second generations might just tip the scales depending on your needs. Whether you’re dipping your toes into the waters of the best smart displays the first time or considering an upgrade, this comprehensive comparison between the Echo Show 8 1st and 2nd generation will assist you in avoiding buyer’s remorse by making an informed decision.
Original model, good HD display and sound. Basic smart display features via Alexa. Likely a less refined design than the 2nd Gen.
Upgraded model with a better camera (possibly auto-framing), more responsive display, and potentially improved sound. Likely has design and connectivity enhancements (e.g., Amazon Sidewalk).
| Device | Pros | Cons |
| Amazon Echo Show 8 (1st gen) Review | More budget-friendlyCompact design fits anywhereIdentical display resolution (1280 × 800)Same core Alexa functionalityPrivacy features included | Limited color optionsOlder, slower processorNo auto-framing during video callsMediocre 1MP camera |
| Amazon Echo Show 8 (2nd gen)Review | Slightly improved speakersAuto-framing technology for video callsSuperior 13MP camera (13× better than 1st gen)More modern color optionsFaster processor for smoother operation | Same display quality as 1st genPerformance improvement barely noticeable for basic tasksMinimal visual design changes from 1st genHigher price point |
What Sets Them Apart
As the saying goes, don’t judge a book by its cover, and this couldn’t be more true when comparing the Amazon Echo 8 1st gen vs 2nd gen. While they may look nearly identical at first glance, the devil is in the details. The most significant difference between these two devices is the impressive jump from a humble 1MP camera to a robust 13MP camera that would make any video-calling enthusiast sit up and take notice.
The Echo Show 8 (2nd gen) also brings a slightly faster processor to the table, but for day-to-day voice assistant interactions, you might not notice much difference. Both devices offer the same 8-inch display with identical resolution, proving that some things are worth keeping consistent when comparing Echo Show 8 1st vs 2nd.
Design and Build Quality: Family Resemblance
When placed side by side, the Echo Show 8 1st gen and 2nd gen could easily be mistaken for twins. Both feature the same wedge-shaped design with an 8-inch display angled for optimal viewing. The dimensions remain unchanged at 135mm × 200mm × 99mm, with both weighing in at a portable 1.04kg.
However, the family resemblance ends when it comes to color options. The Echo Show 8 (1st gen) comes dressed in either Charcoal (dark grey) or Sandstone (cream), while the Echo 8 (2nd gen) offers Charcoal or Glacier White options. There’s a subtle difference between 1st and 2nd gen Echo Show 8, but that difference worth considering if the device needs to blend with your home decor. Build quality remains consistent across generations, with both featuring the same mesh fabric covering the speakers. Both models also include the privacy-conscious camera cover that doubles as a microphone mute, showing that Amazon understands that in the realm of smart home control, privacy features aren’t just nice-to-haves; they’re necessities.
Display and Visual Experience
If you were hoping for a display upgrade in the 2nd generation, you might be disappointed to learn that both models feature identical 8-inch touchscreens with 1280×800 resolution. This isn’t necessarily a bad thing; the display is bright, clear, and perfectly suitable for viewing weather forecasts, watching recipe videos, or even catching up on your favorite shows through media streaming services.
Both Echo 8 1st gen vs 2nd handle glare reasonably well and offer good viewing angles, making them suitable for placement in various locations around your home. The touchscreen responsiveness is where you might notice a slight improvement in the 2nd gen, thanks to its upgraded processor, but the difference isn’t dramatic enough to be a deciding factor on its own.
Camera Capabilities in Echo Show 8 (1st Gen) Vs Echo Show 8 (2nd Gen)
Here’s where the rubber meets the road. If you’re someone who regularly keeps in touch with friends and family through video calling, the differences between Echo Show 8 1st gen and 2nd gen are night and day. The 1st generation’s modest 1MP camera gets the job done but produces grainy, less-than-impressive video quality.
In stark contrast, the Echo Show 8 (2nd gen) boasts a stellar 13MP camera, the same found in the premium Echo Show 10, delivering crystal-clear video that will have your call recipients commenting on the improved quality. But the 2nd gen doesn’t just stop at better resolution; it also introduces auto-framing technology that keeps you centered in the frame even as you move around during calls.
This “follow me” feature means you’re no longer tethered to one spot during your conversations, adding a layer of convenience that the 1st gen simply can’t match in the Amazon Echo Show 8 2nd generation vs 1st comparison.
Audio Performance and Subtle Improvements
When it comes to pumping out your favorite tunes or clearly relaying Alexa’s responses, both generations perform admirably. Looking at Echo Show 8 1st gen vs 2nd gen sound quality, the 2nd gen features slightly larger dual speakers (2 × 2.05″ versus 2 × 2″ in the 1st gen) and specifically mentions a frequency range of 20Hz-20000Hz, though this specification isn’t provided for the 1st gen in our sources. Both models incorporate passive bass radiators for richer sound, making them suitable for casual music listening or podcast enjoyment. While audiophiles might want to look elsewhere for their primary music playback device, both Echo 8 1st gen vs 2nd gen models deliver audio quality that punches above their weight class for devices of this size.
Processing Power and Performance: Under the Hood
The Amazon Show 8 1st and 2nd gen comparison reveals that the 2nd gen Echo Show 8 runs on a newer MediaTek MT8183 processor, an upgrade from the MT8163 chip found in the 1st gen. On paper, this should translate to snappier performance when navigating menus, loading content, or interacting with Alexa capabilities.
In practice, however, the difference between Echo Show 8 1st gen and 2nd gen is subtle at best for most everyday tasks. Both devices respond to voice commands with similar speed, and the basic voice assistant functions feel equally responsive.
You might notice the improved processing power when swiping through multiple screens or running more complex applications, but for simple queries and commands, the 1st gen remains perfectly capable.
Alexa and Smart Home Integration: Equally Capable
When it comes to the core Alexa functionality, there’s virtually no difference in the Echo Show 8 1st vs 2nd gen models. Both devices respond to the same voice commands, control the same smart home devices, and offer identical integration with Amazon’s ecosystem of services.
Ask either generation about the weather, and you’ll receive the same audible response with an on-screen display showing hourly forecasts, wind speed, and feels-like temperature. Both allow you to stream music from services like Spotify and Amazon Music, as well as video content from Netflix and Prime Video. If your primary use case revolves around these basic best smart display functions, the 1st gen offers essentially the same experience as its newer sibling.
Specifications Comparison
| Feature | Echo Show 8 (1st Gen) | Echo Show 8 (2nd Gen) |
| Display | 8″ touchscreen with 1280×800 resolution | 8″ touchscreen with 1280×800 resolution |
| Camera | 1MP | 13MP with auto-framing |
| Processor | MediaTek MT8163 | MediaTek MT8163 |
| Speakers | 2 × 2″ with passive bass radiator | 2 × 2.05″ with passive bass radiator |
| Audio Frequency | Not specified | 20Hz-20000Hz |
| Microphones | 4 far-field | 4 far-field |
| Dimensions | 200mm × 135mm × 99mm | 200mm × 135mm × 99mm |
| Weight | 1.04kg | 1.04kg |
| Wi-Fi | 802.11n (Wi-Fi 4) | 802.11n (Wi-Fi 4) |
| Colors | Charcoal, Sandstone | Charcoal, Glacier White |
| Price | $109.99 / £99.99 / AU$169 | $129.99 / £119.99 / AU$199 |
| Year of Release | 2019 | 2021 |
User Experience In Daily Life
In the hustle and bustle of daily life, how do the Echo Show 8 1st and 2nd generation devices stack up? For checking the weather while you’re rushing to get dressed, asking about your calendar while packing lunches, or controlling your smart home devices as you head out the door, both generations perform identically.
The difference between Echo Show 8 1st gen and 2nd gen becomes apparent in specific use cases. If you’re working from home and frequently participate in video conferences, the 2nd gen’s superior camera and auto-framing feature might save you from awkwardly adjusting your position or dealing with poor video quality. If you use your Echo Show to follow along with cooking tutorials in the kitchen, the ability to remain in the frame as you move between the counter and stove could be genuinely useful.
For passive uses like displaying photos, acting as a sophisticated alarm clock, or serving as a countertop companion for quick information, the Echo Show 8 1st gen vs 2nd remains completely serviceable, offering nearly the same user interface and functionality. Some users on Reddit forums have noted that for these basic uses, the upgrade isn’t necessary.
Price and Value Proposition: Bang for Your Buck
With a price difference, the question becomes: is the upgrade worth it? If you’re buying your first Echo Show 8, spending a bit more for the significantly better camera and slightly improved performance in the Echo Show 8 2nd gen vs 1st gen might make sense, especially if you anticipate using video calling features frequently.
For existing 1st gen owners, the decision hinges almost entirely on how much you value improved video call quality. If your Echo Show primarily serves as an information display and smart home hub rather than a communication device, the upgrade may not justify the expense. For context, many users also consider the Google Nest Hub (2nd gen) as an alternative, though it lacks the camera altogether.
Who Should Buy Either Device
| Buy the Echo Show 8 (1st gen) if | Buy The Echo Show 8 (2nd gen) if |
| You are a Budget-conscious shopper looking to enter the smart display ecosystemYou primarily interested in smart home control, information queries, and media playbackYou rarely use video calling features or aren’t concerned with video qualityYou are looking for a secondary Echo device for less-frequented areas of the home | You are a regular user of video calling features who values clear image qualityYou move around during calls and would benefit from auto-framingYou appreciate having the latest technology, even if the improvements are incrementalYou prefer the Glacier White color option for your home decor |
As they say, if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it! If these basic functions align with your needs, the 1st gen delivers them competently at a lower price point.
If you live by the mantra go big or go home, the 2nd gen’s camera upgrade represents a substantial improvement in one specific area, even if other enhancements are more modest.
As with most technology decisions, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. But armed with this detailed comparison of Amazon Echo Show 8 1st gen vs 2nd gen, you can make a choice that aligns with your specific needs and use cases, ensuring your smart home technology works for you, not the other way around.
What are the main differences between the Echo Show 8 (1st Gen) and Echo Show 8 (2nd Gen)?
The primary differences lie in the camera and processor. The 2nd Gen features a 13MP camera with auto-framing capabilities, enhancing video call experiences by keeping you centered in the frame. It also boasts a faster MediaTek MT8183 processor, offering smoother performance. In contrast, the 1st Gen has a 1MP camera and a MediaTek MT8163 processor.
Is the upgraded camera on the 2nd Gen model worth it for video calls?
Yes, the 13MP camera on the Echo Show 8 (2nd Gen) significantly improves video call quality, providing clearer images and the ability to pan and zoom to keep you in frame. This is a substantial upgrade over the 1MP camera in the 1st Gen model, which lacks these features.
Do both models support the same Alexa features and smart home controls?
Both generations offer similar Alexa functionalities, including voice commands, smart home device control, and streaming services like Netflix and Prime Video. The core Alexa experience remains consistent across both models.
Is it worth upgrading from the 1st Gen to the 2nd Gen Echo Show 8?
If you frequently use video calls or desire a faster, more responsive device, upgrading to the 2nd Gen is beneficial due to its superior camera and processor. However, if these enhancements aren’t crucial for your usage, the 1st Gen still offers a robust smart display experience.
